We're sorry. An error has occurred
Please cancel or retry.
The interpretation of UN Security Council resolutions
Some error occured while loading the Quick View. Please close the Quick View and try reloading the page.
- Format:
-
08 June 2027

This book examines the problematic question of how resolutions of the United Nations Security Council should be interpreted. As the Council’s powers have expanded over time, the need for a coherent interpretive method applicable to its acts has become increasingly pressing.
The study argues that the interpretive framework provided by the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, though not formally applicable to resolutions, offers a valuable point for departure when applied by analogy to these acts. Drawing on the practice of courts, States, and UN organs, the book proposes an original interpretive approach that adapts the Vienna rules to the Council’s distinctive nature as an organ of an international organisation. In doing so, it contributes to a deeper understanding of interpretation in international law by reassessing the continuing relevance of the Vienna Convention method beyond treaty interpretation.
LAW / International, International law, POLITICAL SCIENCE / International Relations / General, POLITICAL SCIENCE / International Relations / Treaties, Public international law: treaties and other sources
Introduction
0.1 Premise of the book
0.2 Aim and methodological approach: analogy as the guiding method for identifying interpretive rules
0.3 Structure of the book
1 In search of a method for interpreting Security Council resolutions: paving the way for analogical analysis
1.1 Introduction
1.2 Methods of interpretation in international law: does one size fit all?
1.3 The Vienna Convention method and Security Council resolutions: an ambiguous relationship
1.4 The place of Security Council’s decisions in the system of international law sources
1.5 The format and adoption procedure of Security Council’s decisions
1.5.1 Resolutions
1.5.2 Presidential statements and other acts through which the Security Council may adopt decisions
1.5.3 Acts adopted by subsidiary organs
1.6 The effects of Security Council’s acts
1.7 The peculiar features of Security Council resolutions as a basis for the development of their interpretive method
1.7.1 The unilateral nature of the acts
1.7.2 The political nature of the organ
1.7.3 The “executive” nature of the powers exercised
1.7.4 The institutional background
1.8 Concluding remarks
2 Testing the application of the general rule of interpretation under Article 31 VCLT to Security Council resolutions
2.1 Introduction
2.2 The theoretical basis for transposing the Vienna Convention rules to the interpretation of Security Council resolutions: the analogical reasoning
2.3 The recurring references to Article 31 VCLT in the international practice concerning the interpretation of Security Council resolutions
2.4 Good faith
2.5 The literal canon: the “ordinary” and “special” meaning of terms
2.5.1 The meaning of operative verbs and their impact on the determination of resolutions’ bindingness
2.5.2 The development of standard terms through Security Council’s practice: between ordinary meaning, special meaning and legal effects
2.5.3 The occasional emergence of strictly literal approaches and their limits
2.6 The contextual canon
2.6.1 The multifaceted role of resolutions’ preambles
2.6.2 The role of annexes and the determination of their legal status as an issue of interpretation
2.6.3 Other elements of context pursuant to Article 31(2) VCLT
2.7 The teleological canon
2.7.1 The central role of the teleological canon in the practice of international interpreters of resolutions
2.7.2 The problematic identification of the telos in Security Council resolutions: objective purpose or subjective intention of the organ?
2.8 Subsequent agreements, subsequent practice and the means of authentic interpretation
2.8.1 The Security Council as the organ entitled to render authentic interpretation
2.8.2 The means for expressing the Council’s authentic interpretation
2.8.3 The legal value of authentic interpretation
2.9 Concluding remarks
3 Testing the application of Article 32 VCLT to Security Council resolutions
3.1 Introduction
3.2 The objective v. subjective approach and the solution adopted in the Vienna Convention in Article
3.3 The identification of the travaux préparatoires and the circumstances surrounding the adoption of a document: a selection based on quality and accessibility
3.4 The scholarly rejection of the Vienna Convention hierarchy in interpreting resolutions: the arguments for a direct resort to travaux préparatoires
3.4.1 The limited quality of resolutions’ texts as a justification for the more frequent resort to travaux préparatoires
3.4.2 The resort to travaux préparatoires via teleological interpretation
3.4.3 The absence of a true distinction between primary and supplementary means in treaty interpretation
3.5 International practice on the application of Article 32 to Security Council resolutions
3.5.1 The ambiguous position of the International Court of Justice in Namibia and Kosovo
3.5.2 Explicit confirmation of the subsidiary nature of travaux préparatoires
3.5.3 The use of travaux préparatoires to confirm the meaning resulting from the application of Article 31 VCLT
3.5.4 The use of travaux préparatoires to determine meaning under the conditions of Article 32 VCLT
3.5.5 The illusion of direct resort to travaux préparatoires in international practice
3.6 Countering the traditional narrative: the arguments in favour of the application of the Vienna Convention hierarchy to Security Council resolutions
3.6.1 The continued relevance of the subsidiary nature of travaux préparatoires in treaty interpretation
3.6.2 An explanation for the more frequent resort to preparatory works in the interpretation of resolutions
3.6.3 The features of resolutions as reasons to reaffirm the hierarchy
3.7 Lack of transparency within the Security Council in the negotiating phase
3.8 Absence of participation of non-members of the Council
3.9 Concluding remarks
4 Security Council resolutions and their potential conflict with other rules of international law: ensuring consistency through strong and weak interpretive presumptions
4.1 Introduction
4.2 Interpretation as an instrument for the prevention of normative conflicts
4.2.1 Normative conflicts, interpretation and interpretive presumptions
4.2.2 Systemic integration under Article 31(3)(c) VCLT as a weak conflict avoidance technique applicable to horizontal normative relationships
4.2.3 Strong consistent interpretation as a general principle applicable to hierarchical normative relationships
4.3 The insufficiency of Article 31(3)(c) VCLT to address all normative conflicts between Security Council resolutions and other rules of international law
4.4 Legal limits to the power of the Security Council to disregard rules of general international law
4.5 The interpretive consequences of the Security Council’s (limited) powers to derogate from general international law: the role of presumptions of conformity
4.5.1 The presumption of conformity to the UN Charter
4.5.2 The presumption of conformity to human rights
4.6 The ECtHR’s presumption of conformity to human rights as a strong conflict avoidance interpretive strategy
4.7 The ICTY presumption of conformity to customary law: conformity to human rights in disguise
4.7.1 The rejection of presumptions of conformity to State sovereignty and its corollaries
4.8 The hypothesis of a presumption against authorisations to the use of force
4.9 The hypothesis of a presumption of conformity to Heads of State immunity before the ICC
4.10 Deviating from the Vienna model: strong presumptions of conformity as an expression of the hierarchical relationship between Security Council resolutions and their constitutive instrument
5 Conclusion
5.1 The analysis performed in the book and its main findings
5.1.1 The convergent trend
5.1.2The divergent trend
5.2 The book’s broader contribution to the theory of interpretation
Select bibliography
Table of treaties and UN documents Table of cases