We're sorry. An error has occurred
Please cancel or retry.
Critical Approaches to Automated Text Recognition
Some error occured while loading the Quick View. Please close the Quick View and try reloading the page.
- Format:
-
20 May 2027

Over the past decade, Automated Text Recognition (ATR) has evolved from a technology with potential, to one now accurate enough to be routinely integrated into digitisation pipelines across heritage institutions and research projects. By harnessing artificial intelligence to transcribe historical documents at unprecedented scale, ATR is transforming how we access, study, and interact with the handwritten record – but what impact are these technologies having? What are the potential benefits and risks, and what new questions do they allow us to ask of our handwritten past?
This ground-breaking edited collection gathers diverse and international perspectives on the complexities of ATR across a range of contexts to critically examine ATR technologies. Emphasising the need for critical analyses to guide future developments, the contributions grapple with algorithmic transparency, the erosion of palaeographical expertise, the displacement of human and volunteer labour, questions of data sovereignty and Indigenous rights, the loss of material and bibliographic context in digitized text, the environmental toll of computation, and the gap between the promise of seamless access and the structural limits that remain.
Timely and authoritative, this book is essential reading for anyone working with digitized heritage collections, urging readers to reflect on how ATR is reshaping our engagement with digital and historical texts, the institutions that host them, and the use and users of such resources.
Melissa Terras is Professor of Digital Cultural Heritage at Edinburgh College of Art, University of Edinburgh, UK. She has previously edited Electronic Legal Deposit (with Paul Gooding) and Library Catalogues as Data (with Paul Gooding and Sarah Ames).
Joe Nockels is Lecturer in Digital Humanities in Information Studies at the University of Glasgow, UK.
Paul Gooding is Professor of Library Studies and Digital Scholarship at the University of Glasgow, UK.
Sarah Ames is Digital Scholarship Librarian at the National Library of Scotland, UK.
Introduction - Melissa Terras and Joe Nockels
Chapter 1: Text First! Multimodal Data Augmentation for Automated Recognition of Handwritten Premodern Italian Manuscripts - Serena Carlamaria Crespi and Carlos-Emiliano González-Gallardo
Chapter 2: Braille Character Recognition: The Study of Tactile Texts - Ellen Forget
Chapter 3: Open Histories, Accessible Futures: Democratising Access to Classical Nahuatl Archives through Handwritten Text Recognition - Patricia Murrieta-Flores, Francisco Cruz-Ríos, Salvador Reyes Equiguas, Eduardo H. Gorobets Martins, Gemma Bel Enguix, Erika Aceves-Xolotzin, Alicia Mayahua, Victor Quiahua, Ricardo Valadez-Vázquez, Julieta Flores-Muñoz, Ben Lemming, Albert A. Palacios, Kelly McDonough, and Alexander Sánchez Díaz
Chapter 4: Through a Human Lens: The Impact of Changing and Declining Handwriting on Handwritten Text Recognition for Historical Documents - Marco Humbel, Julianne Nyhan, Alicia Hughes and Yuewei Fu
Chapter 5: 'The voung man': Digitisation, Remediation, and the History of OCR Correction - Owen Leonard
Chapter 6: Confabulated Transliterations? Managing the Lure of Plausibility in LLM-Detected Arabic Terms in an Early Modern Lexicon - Sarah Lang, Jonas Müller-Laackman, Hazem Lashen, and Farzad Mahootian
Chapter 7: The Evolving Status of ATR-Generated Transcriptions in Digitised Archive Environments: A Critical Perspective - C. Annemieke Romein, Andreas Weber, and Jos Mooijweer
Chapter 8: From Recognition to Infrastructure: Requirements for, and Consequences of, Automated Text Recognition Workflows - Dario Kampkaspar
Chapter 9: ‘Armchair Archivists’ and ATR: Volunteer Perspectives from the Joseph Hooker Correspondence Project - John R. Schaefer
Chapter 10: “Considering the harm it does, I have to disagree”: Teaching ATR in an Era of AI Refusal - Paul Gooding, Joe Nockels, Melissa Terras and Ash Charlton